Guides
How to spot fake local news sites
Some sites look like hometown papers but are templated, automated or politically funded. The warning signs and how to check who is behind a site.
As traditional local papers have shrunk or closed, other websites have filled the space with local-sounding names: the "County Times," the "Valley Reporter," the "Capital City Today." Many are legitimate independent outlets. Some are not. They look like local newspapers but publish little original reporting, are produced by networks that run hundreds of near-identical sites, and in some cases are funded by political or commercial interests that are not disclosed to readers.
The term pink slime journalism is often used for these sites. Researchers at Columbia University's Tow Center for Digital Journalism have tracked networks of them for years, and by 2020 counted more than 1,200 sites in one network alone. Such sites have been linked to political groups on the right and on the left. They tend to multiply around elections and in places with little other local coverage; see news desert.
A newer variation is sites that publish large volumes of text generated by AI tools, rewritten from other outlets' reporting, under local-sounding names.
Warning signs
No single sign proves a site is fake, and some legitimate small newsrooms show one or two. Several together are a reason for caution.
Who writes it
- No bylines, or bylines that are generic ("Staff report," "News Service") on almost every story.
- Writers you cannot find anywhere else, with no photo, biography or history of local work.
- No masthead or staff list, or one with no editor's name.
Where it is
- No physical address or local phone number, or only a P.O. box or an address in another state.
- No sign of being in the community: no photos from local events, no reporters at meetings, no corrections from local readers.
What it publishes
- Templated stories: lists of gas prices, unemployment figures, government contracts, real estate sales or crime statistics filled in for each town with the same sentence structure.
- Stories that appear word for word on many other sites with different place names. Searching a distinctive sentence in quotation marks often turns them up.
- Little or no coverage of ordinary local news such as council votes, high school sports, weather, obituaries or traffic.
- A political slant presented as news, especially stories about one candidate or issue appearing in volume before an election, often based only on press releases or one side's statements.
- Generic or mismatched images, such as stock photos or pictures from other places.
How it presents itself
- A name that imitates an established local paper or a defunct one.
- No "About" page, or one that is vague about ownership and funding.
- No corrections policy or way to contact the editors.
- Printed copies or mailers that arrive unrequested shortly before an election.
How to check who is behind a site
- Read the About, Contact and Privacy pages. Legitimate outlets usually name their owner, editor and location. Note any company name, even in the fine print or copyright line.
- Search the company name. Look for news coverage of the owner, other sites it runs, and any connection to campaigns, consultants or advocacy groups.
- Look up the company in state business records. Secretaries of state publish business registrations, which list the registered agent and sometimes officers.
- Check political spending records. Payments from campaigns or political committees to a publisher may appear in Federal Election Commission filings or state campaign finance reports.
- Look for a nonprofit's filings. A site claiming nonprofit status should be able to name its parent organization; nonprofit tax filings are public and list major officers. Legitimate nonprofit newsrooms usually list their funders.
- Check the domain. Domain registration lookups show when a site was created, though owner details are often hidden. A site that claims a long history but registered its domain recently deserves a closer look.
- Search for the site's name with "network" or "pink slime." Research groups, journalists and media-rating organizations have published lists and investigations of known networks.
What legitimate local news looks like
Local newsrooms vary widely in size and polish. Good signs include named reporters who cover meetings in person, a local office or editor you can contact, a published corrections practice, a mix of routine and original stories, and clear disclosure of ownership and funding. Established local papers, TV stations, public media and nonprofit newsrooms all have these, and many independent newsletters do too.
Opinion is not the same as fake news. A clearly labeled opinion section, or an outlet that openly says it has a point of view, is being transparent with readers. The problem is undisclosed purpose presented as neutral local reporting.
Habits that help
- Cross-check important local stories with a second outlet or with the primary document: the agenda, minutes, court record or official release.
- Be cautious with stories that arrive by mail, text or social media just before an election.
- Know your reliable sources in advance; see the guide to finding local news about your town.
- Support the newsrooms that do real local reporting, which is the most direct way to keep reliable coverage in your community; see the guide to supporting local journalism.
On 4LocalNews, each story links to the outlet that published it, so you can apply these checks to the source yourself.